Looking For The Best Concealed Carry Holster For Smith and Wesson Shield?

Here’s a look at our favorites, including our top pick – CYA Supply Co. IWB Holster Fits: Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9MM.

#1 Best Concealed Carry Holster For Smith and Wesson Shield


When it comes to carrying a concealed firearm, a good holster is indispensable. Your holster needs to keep your weapon firmly and securely in place, but it also needs to keep the weapon accessible for a quick and silent draw. After all, it defeats the purpose of carrying a concealed weapon if you can’t get to it in time.

A good holster also needs to hit the sweet spot between comfort and durability. It should be strong and sturdy enough to withstand the rigors of daily use, but it needs to be comfortable enough that you don’t dread wearing it every day. That may sound pretty simple, but there are a lot of negative reviews out there that prove it can be tough to pull off.

The good news is there are plenty of great holsters that provide security, accessibility, durability, and comfort. You just need to know what to look for, and it certainly helps when you can rely on the reviews of other gun owners.


What to look for in a concealed carry holster

As you’re looking for the best concealed carry holster for your Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, here are a few tips on what to look for:

  • Hard case holsters – you can’t beat the durability of a hard case holster. They can cause pressure points when you bend and sit so they’re not for everyone, but their hardy construction means they’re meant to last a lifetime. Kydex is the gold standard for quality and durability in hard case holsters.
  • Soft case holsters – don’t think that soft case holsters are inferior because they’re made with fabric, because that’s definitely not true. Soft holsters that are made with high-quality materials can still be durable enough to last a lifetime, and they’re much more breathable and comfortable than hard case holsters. Look for soft holsters made with leather or neoprene.
  • IWB – in the world of holsters, IWB stands for “in-waistband.” An IWB holster typically has a fastener that attaches to your belt, and it’s worn inside your waistband (in contrast to a hip holster that’s on the outside) for better concealability.
  • Ankle holsters – if you find IWB holsters to be uncomfortable, consider going with an ankle holster instead. Look for a holster with at least two adjustable straps to prevent slippage (one for the calf and one for the ankle) and be sure to measure your leg to make sure you get the right size straps.
  • Ambidextrous holsters – if you’re a leftie, you’ll need to get a specialized IWB that allows for left-handed draws or an ankle holster that’s ambidextrous (can be mounted on either side of your leg).


CYA Supply Co. IWB Holster Fits: Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9MM

Best CYA Supply Co. concealed carry holster for Smith and Wesson Shield

Read customer reviews


If you’re looking for a highly rated and widely recommended holster, go with this IWB Holster by CYA Supply Co. It’s designed specifically for use with the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield (9mm or .40 S&W), so you’re guaranteed a perfect fit.

The holster fits comfortably inside your waistband with a 1.5-inch belt clip, and it has a sweat guard that covers the full length of the slide for extra protection against moisture accumulation on hot and humid days. The retention pressure and carry angle are both adjustable with the included Hex Allen Key, and the Posi-Click audible retention lock system keeps your gun safely locked in place at all times.

CYA Supply Co. uses Boltaron thermoplastic, a plastic that outperforms Kydex in terms of abrasion resistance, chemical resistance, impact resistance, hardness, and durability. Boltaron keeps its form better in high heat situations, too.

Also, unlike most Kydex holsters that are molded straight to the shape of the gun, the IWB Holster employs some recessing around the slide release and safety to create a smoother draw and reduce the holster-wear on your weapon.


Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster For S&W M&P Shield

Best Relentless Tactical concealed carry holster for Smith and Wesson Shield

Read customer reviews


If you’d prefer a soft case waistband holster, you can’t go wrong with The Defender IWB Holster by Relentless Tactical. It’s handmade by American craftsmen with genuine USA bull hide leather, and you won’t find any cheap, synthetic materials anywhere on the holster.

The result is classic American craftsmanship with top-notch comfort, function, and durability. It’s built to last a lifetime, and the product is backed by the company’s lifetime warranty to guarantee that promise. It’s also highly versatile, as it can fit most full-size and compact handguns in 9mm, .40, and .45.

The Defender was designed for optimal concealment and ease of access, and the user reviews clearly indicate that the holster delivers on both of those objectives. The leather composition also makes it significantly more comfortable to wear than a standard Kydex holster, so it’s a holster you won’t dread wearing. I personally like how the company doesn’t use any synthetic parts, so you don’t have to worry about shoddy workmanship or cheap materials.


LIRISY Inside The Waistband Holster | Gun Concealed Carry IWB Holster | Fits S&W M&P Shield

Best LIRISY concealed carry holster for Smith and Wesson Shield

Read customer reviews


For those of you who are on a tighter budget, take a look at the IWB holster by LIRISY. It comes at a price point that doesn’t break the bank, its soft-material construction makes it comfortable for everyday use, and it comes in a variety of sizes to fit most handguns—including guns with a light or laser attachment.

The LIRISY IWB Holster has ultra-thin neoprene on the outside for maximum breathability, softness, and comfort, with 600D nylon material on the inside for long-term durability. Because the holster is soft inside and out, you won’t have to worry about pain or pressure when you bend or sit down.

There’s a strong snap button to keep your gun secure yet accessible for a quick and silent draw, and a heavy-duty belt clip to keep the holster in place when you draw. It’s easy to conceal with minimal printing on the case, and the company backs the holster with a lifetime guarantee.

If you’re buying a holster for a Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, go with the small size holster. For larger guns with a slide length of 6.5” – 7.2”, you’ll need to upgrade to the large holster.


LIRISY Ankle Holster for Concealed Carry | Non-Slip with Calf Strap Holster

Best LIRISY Ankle Holster concealed carry holster for Smith and Wesson Shield

Read customer reviews


If you like the look and feel of the LIRISY IWB Holster but would prefer to carry your gun on your angle, you’ll be happy to know that the company also makes a soft-shell neoprene ankle holster. Like the IWB version, this one is made with breathable, durable neoprene.

It’s soft, comfortable, and won’t itch, yet it’s thick enough to handle the weight of your gun. For added comfort, the holster has a foam pad that extends beyond the barrel to make sure you don’t have to deal with any pinching, poking, or rubbing.

The LIRISY Ankle Holster has a calf strap to prevent it from slipping, and an elastic retention strap with a metal snap for a quick, silent draw and release. It also has an ambidextrous design that lets you strap up on the left or right side of your leg, so it’s a good choice for left-handed shooters. Of course, this holster also comes with LIRISY’s lifetime warranty, so you’re guaranteed a product that will last a lifetime.

In terms of size, this holster has a universal fit that can secure any revolver, subcompact, or compact handgun. There are two sizes, and they’re both based on your leg size—the 15-inch band fits up to 13-inch legs, and the 17-inch band fits up to 15-inch legs. If you’re going to wear the strap over your boots, go with the 17-inch band.


Ankle Holster for Concealed Carry | Universal Leg Gun Holster for Glock 43 42 19 36 26, Smith & Wesson Bodyguard M&P Shield

Best LPV Ankle Holster concealed carry holster for Smith and Wesson Shield

Read customer reviews


Here’s another great ankle holster option. The LPV Ankle Holster is a premium holster made with breathable, padded neoprene. It can easily withstand the rigors of daily use, but it doesn’t sacrifice anything in terms of comfort or concealability. It’s highly versatile, ambidextrous, can handle any size handgun, and includes an extra magazine pouch.

One of the neat things about this ankle holster is that it’s designed to conform to the shape of the human leg. That may not sound like a big deal, but it makes a big difference when it comes to comfort, supporting your firearm, and preventing slippage. You can easily adjust the fit with the top and bottom straps, and users report that the heavy-duty Velcro does a fantastic job of keeping the holster secure all day. The retention strap band keeps your gun secured tightly in place, yet the thumb break quick release mechanism keeps it easy to draw quickly and silently.



If you’re looking for a hard-shell IWB holster, go with the CYA Supply Co. IWB Holster. If you’d prefer a soft-shell IWB holster, I’d highly recommend Relentless Tactical’s The Defender Holster. For those of you who’d prefer an ankle holster, I’d pick the LPV Ankle Holster.